125 Top Picksfrom a year of Silver CelebrationsTop California Wine of 2009
98 Marston Family Vineyard, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Spring Mountain District, Napa Valley
Intense inky hue with a black garnet rim. Aromas of campfire, bacon fat, leather and vanilla mingle with an uplifting menthol nuance. Zaftig blackberry and raspberry fruit flavors with notes of graphite, baker’s chocolate and drying, fine-grain tannins. Lengthy cherry-chocolate finish with a lingering smoky nuance. An exceptional, well-made Cab and a prime example of Spring Mountain fruit at its best. $100 / 500 cases
96 Duckhorn Vineyards, 2006 Merlot
Napa Valley
Black-garnet hue. Lovely mixed aromas of blueberry, raspberry and kirsch. A rush of black cherry fruit on entry laced with flinty mineral accents and fine-grain, youthful tannins. Creamy fruit marks the finish. Taut in structure and cellar-worthy. A prime example of power and finesse: classic Napa fruit, true to its varietal character, crafted into a memorable, prototype Merlot. $52 / 31,631 cases
95 Ehlers Estate, 2006 “1886 ” Cabernet Sauvignon
St. Helena, Napa Valley
Black-garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. A ripe, heady bouquet of blueberry jam, coconut, shaved pencil and glove leather. Sweet raspberry and maraschino cherry flavors with dusty, mineral-laden tannins. Rich, lingering finish imbued with black fruit, sweet oak, forgiving tannins and balanced acidity. $95 / 2,100 cases
95 Kathryn Hall, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Intense black-garnet hue. Attractive, fruit-driven bouquet emitting fresh black cherry and blueberry with hints of flint, charcoal and clove. Creamy black cherry fruit imbued with youthful yet even tannins and fresh acidity. A stalwart Napa Cab displaying excellent length and purity of fruit. $75 / 3,000 cases
95 Rubicon Estate, 2005 Rubicon
Rutherford, Napa Valley
Black-garnet hue with a ruby rim. Upfront aromas of black cherry, coffee bean and graphite. Opulent cherry-chocolate flavors laced with minerals and youthful wood tannins. Stylish, lasting finish showcases purity of fruit (98% cabernet/2% petit verdot), balance and structure. $145
95 Sanford, 2007 Chardonnay
La Entrada, Sta. Rita Hills
Lightly burnished gold hue. A well-defined nose of pineapple, caramel and lightly toasted oak. Tasty butterscotch and lively citrus flavors laced with zesty acids and flinty mineral accents. Youthful, lengthy finish with a fine, Chablis-like intensity. $45 / 217 cases
94 Barnett, 2006 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon
Cyrus Ryan Vineyard, Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Exotic aromas of caramel and maple with fresh red fruit and a heady, Sherry-like note. Dusty cherry and blackberry fruit with notes of licorice and youthful, fine-grain tannins. An expressive, lengthy finish displays excellent weight and structure. $95
94 Barnett, 2006 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon
Rattlesnake Hill, Spring Mtn District, Napa Vly
Black-garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Aromas of black cherry and chocolate fudge with a wisp of chalkiness. Muscular and warming with layers of black cherry, graphite and fine-grain wood tannins. Dusty, mineral-laden finish with a plethora of promising red and black fruit. $125
94 Dry Creek, 2006 Zinfandel
Beeson Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Black-garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Uplifting raspberry aromas with subtler ginger and graphite along with a whiff of menthol. Fresh raspberry dominates the palate with hints of chalky mineral notes and a youthful, supportive cast of tannins. Another well-made, dynamic Zin from a distinguished Dry Creek Valley vineyard planted by Italian immigrants in 1882. $34
94 Dutton Goldfield, 2006 Chardonnay
Dutton Ranch-Rued Vineyard, RRV
Brilliant yellow-gold hue. Fresh aromas of peach, sliced apple, cinnamon and new oak. Zaftig peach, apple and toasted oak flavors with just enough acidic structure to balance the rush of sweetness in the fruit-driven finish. $45
94 Dutton Goldfield, 2006 Pinot Noir
Dutton Ranch, Freestone Hill Vnyd, RRV
Black-garnet hue. Earthy aromas followed by fresh cherry, vanilla, tea and glove leather scents. Tasty, juicy black cherry fruit and plum with well-integrated, combed tannins. Rich, lasting finish with caramel and mocha accents. $58
94 Erba Mountainside, 2004 Merlot
Napa Valley
Brooding garnet hue. Intense plum, chocolate and new leather aromas. Minty blueberry and plum flavors with an edge of flinty mineral accents. Lengthy, plump finish with a lingering toasted oak nuance. $38
94 Far Niente, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Oakville, Napa Valley
Intense purple hue. Blueberry and mint aromas with light graphite undertones. Apparent anise, blackberry and new oak give way to combed tannins and a nervy edge of fresh acidity. A fleshy, intense Cab with a promising future. $125
94 Goldschmidt , 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Vyborny Vineyard Plus, Alexander Vly
Purple hue to the rim. Cedar box and new oak scents with hints of mint, clove and peppermint. Vibrant and peppery with blackberry, dusty graphite and fine-grain tannins. Muscular, promising finish with a rush of black fruit and drying, tart mineral notes. $150
94 Isley, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Single Vineyard Estate, Stags Leap District
Black-garnet hue. Jammy aromas of raspberry and blackberry. Rich and forthcoming with layers of juicy black fruit, drying minerals and coffee bean. Well-oaked finish with a brambly continuation of wild berry flavors that will get even better with time. $55
94 Louis M. Martini, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Lot. No.1, Napa Valley
Attractive black-garnet hue. Forward aromas of blueberry jam and clove with a wisp of peppermint. A well-made, accessible Cab with rich cherry-chocolate flavors, well-integrated tannins and an edge of nervy acidity. Seamless, lingering finish with plenty of stuffing for the cellar. $125
94 Louis M. Martini, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Monte Rosso Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Blackish-garnet hue. An attractive bouquet of blackberry, raspberry and vanillin oak. Earthy cherry and anise flavors with obvious new oak impressions imparting youthful wood tannins. Still somewhat compact and not as showy as the 2004, yet layers of promising fruit auger well for a rewarding and lengthy future. $85
94 Merry Edwards, 2006 Pinot Noir
Meredith Estate, Russian River Valley
Bright garnet hue. Fresh black cherry, clove, flint, rhubarb and basil aromas. A balanced, well-structured wine with crisp cherry and strawberry fruit laced with earthy, woodsy tannins and drying mineral notes. The combination of red fruit and woodland expressions should pair nicely with a variety of foods. $54
94 Patz & Hall, 2006 Pinot Noir
Pisoni Vineyard, Santa Lucia Highlands
Shimmering brick-red hue. Gorgeous bouquet of sweet cherry, light oak and toffee. Remarkable balance and finesse on the palate with tart raspberry and caramel supported by firm, integrated acidity. Tart berry and cherry accents ring on the finish and showcase the best of California Pinot Noir. $80
94 Provenance, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Beckstoffer-To Kalon Vineyard, Napa Valley
Black garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Full bouquet of menthol, raspberry, blueberry and charred oak. Deep-seated rich, classic cabernet fruit character with waves of kirsch, chocolate and mineral flavors; fine tannins and crisp acids support the opulent fruit. Drying, flinty finish. $85
94 Rancho Zabaco, 2006 Toreador Zinfandel
Monte Rosso Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Intense color, purple to the rim. Menthol-laced bouquet emitting ripe plum and blackberry aromas. Velvety texture with layers of minty black fruit and a peppery edge. Thick, juicy finish with lingering charred oak, vanilla and black fruit notes. $60
94 Rosenblum Cellars, 2006 Zinfandel
Maggie’s Reserve, Sonoma Valley
Garnet hue with a feathered, fuchsia rim. Woodsy cedar and redwood aromas with notes of nutmeg, cinnamon and red licorice. Intense wave of black fruit with menthol and mineral laced throughout the flavors. The finish is spiced with cracked black pepper, youthful tannins and a lingering sweetness that refuses to wane. $45
94 Rosenblum Cellars, 2006 Zinfandel
Planchon Vineyard, Contra Costa County
Garnet hue with a feathered rim. Charred, smoky aromas couple with thick, sweet scents of cooked cherry. A supple wine with blackberry, plum, blueberry and chalk accents. Spicy, flinty close with an edge of black pepper and a lingering, molasses-like sweetness. $30
94 Shafer, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Hillside Select, Stags Leap District, Napa Vly
Black garnet hue to the rim. Heady bouquet of cooked cherry, coffee bean and Hershey’s dark chocolate syrup. Round and supple with layered flavors of black cherry, anise and chocolate. Very soft finish; tempting and approachable in its youth. $215
94 Signorello, 2007 Chardonnay
Hope’s Cuvée, Napa Valley
Yellow-gold hue. Heady grilled pineapple, banana and new oak aromas. A fresh mix of lemon drop, pear and apricot flavors laced with toasted oak. Lush and full with a clove-like zing in the finish. $60
94 Signorello, 2006 Padrone
Red Wine, Estate Grown, Napa Valley
Intense purple hue to the rim. Smoky bouquet of kirsch, mocha and maple syrup. Layers of black cherry fruit, baker’s chocolate and drying mineral with youthful tannins providing plenty of grip. A high-energy red that will continue to improve. $110
94 Summers, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Napa Valley
Intense inky hue. Fresh, full aromas of red and black fruit with obvious new oak. Thick flavors of blackberry and sturdy tannins that provide muscular structure. Very spicy, acidic finish with rich, vanillin-oak and layers of promising fruit. $65
94 Vine Cliff Winery, 2006 Chardonnay
Proprietress Reserve, Los Carneros
Yellow-gold hue. Upfront melted butter, oak and peach aromas. Thick and creamy emitting ready-to-drink caramel, dark honey and apple butter flavors. Lasting fruit impressions and a lick of clove in the finish. $60
94 Wallis Family, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Diamond Mountain District, Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Lovely blueberry and ripe plum aromas with a tiramisù-like richness. Silky texture with blackberry and kirsch-like flavors, an edge of mintiness and fine sandpaper tannins. Crisp, dry close with both a prevailing fruitiness and dusty mineral notes. $85
93 Barnett, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Spring Mountain District, Napa Valley
Dense inky hue with a ruby rim. Aromas of black cherry and blueberry with whiffs of charred oak. Thick and expansive with plum and blueberry flavors laced with well-integrated tannins. Excellent length with jam-like intensity and a youthful tartness. Classic mountain fruit. $65
93 Beringer, 2007 Chardonnay
Private Reserve, Napa Valley
Pale gold hue. Forward bouquet of peach, apricot, oak and warm caramel. Well structured and flinty with layers of peach and cinnamon flavors. Lengthy finish with apple butter-like sweetness. $35
93 Calix Cellars, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Masked Man Vineyard, Napa Valley
Youthful, deep garnet hue. An enticing bouquet of clove, kirsch, eucalyptus and basil. Full, ripe flavors of blackberry and blueberry. A balancing mineral nuance caps the finish. $60
93 Caymus, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Attractive bouquet of black cherry, blueberry and coconut. Silky smooth texture and rather appealing in its youth, emitting sweet cherry and mocha flavors. Lengthy, sweet finish, yet a light, spicy, peppery nuance livens up the mix. $70
93 C. Donatiello Winery, 2006 Pinot Noir
Floodgate Vineyard, Old Vines, RRV
Feathered garnet hue. Heady menthol aromas followed by cranberry, toffee, pecan and coffee bean accents. Spicy red licorice flavors laced with rough-hewn, chalky tannins. $57
93 Chalk Hill, 2007 Sauvignon Blanc
Estate, Chalk Hill, Russian River Valley
Bright gold hue. White grapefruit aromas with whiffs of basil and lemon grass. Excellent weight and texture with an expressive grapefruit and poached pear flavor. Lingering mineral accents temper the sweetness in the lengthy finish. $33
93 Chalk Hill, 2006 Chardonnay
Chalk Hill, Russian River Valley
Gold hue. Forward aromas of dark honey, peach, caramel and oak. Unctuous, warm caramel, white peach and pear flavors with a velvet-like texture. Long finish with a flush of butterscotch. $48
93 Clos Pegase, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Hommage, Artist Series Reserve, Napa Valley
Black garnet hue. Ripe aromas of plum, blackberry and new leather. Opulent and jammy with layers of wild berries, fresh acidity and prominent tannins. A rich, licorice-like nuance joins a youthful oakiness in the finish. $95
93 Dashe, 2006 Zinfandel
Florence Vineyard, Dry Creek Valley
Deep garnet hue. Opulent bouquet of warm chocolate, plum and blueberry with a whiff of evergreen. Port-like texture and weight with layers of plum, blueberry, cinnamon and clove flavors. Lengthy finish loaded with fruit and laced with very fine sandpaper tannins. $32
93 Domaine Carneros, 2006 Pinot Noir
Carneros
Soft, shimmering rose hue. Elegant bouquet of pine, mint and pretty, vanillin-laced oak. Soft and creamy on entry with a wonderful blend of sweet/tart cherry, briar and perfectly accented acids. Tart on a cedar-influenced close with light clove and delicately integrated tannins that showcase finesse and balance. $35
93 Donum, 2006 Pinot Noir
Estate Grown, Carneros
Pale garnet hue. Attractive bouquet of smoky bacon fat, tea, rhubarb and red licorice. Sweet, delicate flavors of cherry fruit with basil and fine-grain tannins. The sweetness lingers, yet the earthy character of the wine tempers the richness and balances the close. $65
93 Dry Creek, 2006 Zinfandel
Somer’s Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Healthy garnet hue. Mixed aromas of coffee bean, ginger and lavender. Blackberry, raspberry and baker’s chocolate flavors with drying tannins that provide adept support. Excellent length and weight with lingering notes of oak, flint and chalk. $34
93 Dutton Goldfield, 2006 Pinot Noir
Devil’s Gulch Vineyard, Marin County
Black-garnet hue. Mixed aromas of black cherry, dark honey, cola and violets. Ample black cherry fruit and red licorice with a lick of mocha. Elegant finish with a lingering, toasted oak nuance. $55
93 Dutton Goldfield, 2006 Pinot Noir
Dutton Ranch, Russian River Valley
Dense garnet hue. Classic pinot noir aromas of red raspberry, vanilla and wild cherry with secondary nuances of pomegranate and jasmine. Juicy flavors of red raspberry and black cherry with hints of cola. Silky tannins and impressions of red licorice in the raspberry-driven close. $38
93 Dutton Goldfield, 2006 Pinot Noir
Dutton Ranch, Sanchietti Vineyard, RRV
Deep garnet hue with a feathered rim. Fresh plum and black cherry aromas. Round, supple red and black fruit with dusty, flinty mineral accents. Excellent length and weight with chalky black cherry fruit, charred oak and a spicy clove zing in the close. $58
93 Girard, 2007 Old Vine Zinfandel
Napa Valley
Intense plum hue. Powerful aromas of blackberry, pepper and wintergreen. Jammy flavors of blackberry, plum and mocha. Velvety tannins and hints of bitter chocolate in the lingering close. $25
93 Goldschmidt, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Game Ranch Plus, Oakville
Brooding inky hue. Minty blackberry aromas with hints of charred oak and campfire ash. Seductive, supple black cherry, plum and clove flavors. Youthful finish of chalky tannins, toasted oak and tight-knit fruit ensure a promising future. $150
93 Goldschmidt, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Vyborny Vineyard, Alexander Valley
Purple hue with a feathered rim. Reserved scents of toasted oak, minerals and black cherry. Mouth-coating black cherry fruit and licorice flavors. A muscular, rough-hewn Cab stuffed with spicy black fruit, dusty tannins and lasting mineral impressions. $70
93 Hall, 2006 Merlot
Napa Valley
Dense purple-black hue. Powerful scents of black cherry, menthol and shoe polish. Plush tannins and ripe flavors of black cherry, maple and rum cake. Hints of soy sauce and vanilla in the blackberry-driven close. $28
93 Hollywood & Vine, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
2480, Napa Valley
Intense purple hue. Heady aromas of plum, evergreen, cedar and licorice. Supple, kirsch-like flavors with mixed new oak and mineral accents. Fine tannins balance the apparent richness in the lengthy, creamy finish. $83
93 Joseph Phelps, 2005 Backus
Oakville, Napa Valley
Black-garnet hue. Attractive bouquet of blueberry, graphite and charred oak. Balanced red and black fruit flavors with very fine, flinty tannins. Youthful finish, still somewhat compact and slow to open. A tightly wound Backus that needs time. $225
93 Louis M. Martini, 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon
Monte Rosso Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Attractive garnet hue. Intense aromas of raspberry and heady eucalyptus. Rich black cherry and mocha flavors laced with crisp acids and peppery tannins. Lively, minty close with a mix of oak, cedar and redwood accents. $85
93 Lymar Estate, 2007 Chardonnay
La Sereinité, Russian River Valley
Bright gold hue. Pretty bouquet of peach and dried apricot. Rich, concentrated flavors of tasty apple, cinnamon, dark honey and peach. Notable weight and length. $70
93 Marimar Estate, 2006 Pinot Noir
Don Miguel Vnyd, Earthquake Block, RRV
Very dark, brooding garnet hue. Healthy licorice and cherry aromas with hints of cedar and redwood. Expressive black cherry fruit with coffee bean and anise accents. Spicy clove and mineral notes yield a somewhat youthful finish. $55
93 Matanzas Creek, 2007 Chardonnay
Sonoma Valley
Gold hue with a brass glint. Fresh peach and apple aromas with a whiff of banana peel. Flavors of peach nectar and apple deliver a zing of fresh acidity. Drying mineral impressions surface in the crisp, lengthy finish. $29
93 Matrix Winery, 2006 Zinfandel
Dry Creek Valley
Garnet with a fuchsia rim. Ripe aromas of black fruit and maraschino cherry. Creamy texture imparting raspberry and malted milk flavors with an edge of chalkiness. Very dry, youthful finish with a driving core of raspberry fruit. $45
93 Mazzocco Sonoma, 2006 Zinfandel
Smith Orchard Reserve, Dry Creek Valley
Black-garnet hue. Bouquet of raspberry and ripe raisin with a note of pencil shavings. Vibrant, then supple, raspberry fruit with an attractive, charred nuance laced throughout. Lasting fruit impressions with a fudge brownie-like richness. $50
93 Merriam Vineyards, 2004 Merlot
Russian River Valley
Intense purple hue to the rim. Attractive bouquet of blueberry and ripe plum with an uplifting mintiness. Supple texture with lush black and red fruit flavors and kirsch-like intensity. Lengthy finish with a show of youthful tannins and a rush of sweetness. $30
93 Merriam Vineyards, 2005 Miktos
Red Wine, Sonoma County
Garnet hue with feathered rim. Vanillin-oak aromas followed by black cherry and licorice scents. Kirsch-like flavors with impressive weight and intensity. Drying mineral aftertaste; however, a defined richness lingers in the finish. $50
93 Merry Edwards, 2006 Pinot Noir
Tobias Glen, Russian River Valley
Purple hue to the rim. Slow-developing aromas of plum and dusty oak. Solid core of black cherry fruit with aggressive, fine-grain wood tannins. Tart clove-infused finish with tight-knit, promising fruit. $54
93 Parallel, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate, Napa Valley
Intense garnet hue. Uplifting aromas of raspberry, toasted oak and fudge. Concentrated black cherry fruit with notes of anise and dark chocolate. Lengthy, enjoyable finish with complementary mineral and clove accents. $125
93 Patz & Hall, 2006 Pinot Noir
Chenoweth Ranch, Russian River Valley
Medium crimson hue. Pretty bouquet of violets, briar and black cherry. Notable balance on entry with black cherry, forest floor and crisp, backing acidity deftly framed by fine-combed, oaky tannins. Clean, complex close with honey, caramel and light spice notes and an elegant integration of fruit. $55
93 Robert Craig, 2006 Affinity
Napa Valley
Deep black-garnet hue. Ripe aromas of fruit compote and maraschino cherry. Friendly plum and blueberry fruit with soft tannins that become more aggressive in the finish. Excellent length with pleasant balance between ripe black fruit and drying mineral flavors. Another impressive offering from Robert Craig. $48
93 Rosenblum Cellars, 2006 Zinfandel
Rockpile Road Vineyard, Rockpile
Purple hue to the rim. Lovely bouquet of clove, ginger, vanilla extract, blueberry and plum. Plump with plenty of heft showcasing black cherry and plum with a steely edge of crisp acidity. Youthful, tannic finish with a load of spicy minerals joining the rich fruit. $35
93 Rubissow-Sargent, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Mt. Veeder, Napa Valley
Solid garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. A burst of silky-smooth blackberry fruit followed by chalky mineral flavors. A well-structured, fruit-powered wine with balancing minerality and oak that come together nicely in the finish. $125
93 Sbragia Family, 2006 Chardonnay
Gamble Ranch Vineyard, Napa Valley
An attractive luminous gold hue. Forward grilled pineapple, white peach and vanillin oak aromas. Ripe, thick and juicy with the typical Sbragia lushness front to back. There is a lovely mix of peach, caramel and banana flavors that carry through to a lengthy finish, accented by brown spice. $40
93 Sbragia Family, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Wall Vineyard, Mt. Veeder, Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a feathered rim. Heady aromas of kirsch, mint, blueberry, warm caramel and graphite. Elegant and stylish with supple plum and black cherry fruit laced with spicy oak. Fruit-driven finish with lingering black fruit notes. $75
93 Scott Family Estate, 2006 Pinot Noir
Dijon Clone, Arroyo Seco
Very clean, sparking rose hue. Classic varietal nose with cherry, leather and light tobacco fragrances. Rich and coating on a silky entry with loads of buttery cherry fruit and wonderfully integrated tannins. Tart and tangy on the finish with mulberry, pepper and leather accents wrapped around a ribbon of cherry-infused acids. $39
93 Sequana, 2007 Pinot Noir
Sundawg Ridge Vnyd, Green Valley, RRV
Shimmering rose hue. Pretty nose of boysenberry, dark chocolate and light floral aromas. Tart flavors of cherry and berry bolstered by leather and balancing, crisp acidity. Lush cherry pie and bacon fat notes resonate on the tobacco-edged finish. $50
93 Signorello, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Unfiltered, Estate Grown, Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a feathered rim. A minty bouquet of black fruit and clove. Thick and rich with sticky tannins and juicy black cherry and plum fruit. Crisp, spicy finish laden with drying minerals. $50
93 Silver Oak, 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a feathered rim. A bouquet of menthol and lavender with spicy mixed wood notes. Soft, seductive black fruit laced with mint and evergreen. Seamless, elegant finish with expressive cherry and smoky oak. $100
93 Sojourn, 2007 Pinot Noir
Sangiacomo Vineyards, Sonoma Coast
Medium garnet hue. Complex scents of black cherry, maple and vanilla. Juicy flavors of raspberry, wild cherry and cola knitted with silky tannins. Hints of black pepper in the raspberry-driven close. $48
93 Soñador Cellars, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Napa Valley
Intense purple hue to the rim. Heady aromas of blueberry, blackberry and evergreen with a whiff of graphite. Opulent black fruit flavors imbued with sweet, integrated tannins. Dry, spicy, mineral-laden finish. Displays both heft and structure. $56
93 Spring Mountain Vineyard, 2006 Elivette
Red Wine, Estate, Napa Valley
Solid garnet hue with a ruby rim. Fresh aromas of blackberry, clove, cinnamon stick and a wisp of evergreen. Healthy red and blackberry flavors laced with rustic, fine-grain tannins. The finish is compact and tart; however, this is a big, well-structured wine with great aging potential. $100
93 Tandem, 2006 Pinot Noir
Sangiacomo Vineyards, Sonoma Coast
Light ruby hue. Enticing scents of raspberry and plum with secondary nuances of sandalwood and acacia. Juicy flavors of raspberry and wild cherry. Gentle tannins and layers of wild cherry, maple and vanilla power the endless close. $48
93 Tandem, 2006 Pinot Noir
Silver Pines Vineyard, Sonoma Mountain
Dense, purple-garnet hue. Powerful scents of black cherry, brown sugar and rum cake with secondary nuances of oak and wintergreen. Juicy flavors of raspberry and wild cherry. Silky tannins and hints of vanilla and allspice in the raspberry-spiked close. $60
93 Wrath, 2007 Chardonnay
San Saba Vineyard, Monterey
Light white-gold hue. Distinct scents of oak, mint and forest floor. Buttery integration of grapefruit and big oak flavors deliver a wonderful richness. Toasted grain and citrus elements round out the finish with a superb backing of lemon-tinged acidity. $55
93 ZD Wines, 2007 Chardonnay
California
Yellow-gold hue. A minty nuance joins ripe peach and toasted oak aromas. Apple, pineapple and honey flavors show rather well in youth. Zesty, well-structured finish with ripe tropical fruit and lingering toasted oak. $34
92 Artesa, 2007 Chardonnay
Estate, Carneros
Yellow-gold hue. Upfront aromas of toasted oak, caramel, vanilla and butterscotch. Expansive flavors of ripe apple and peach with drying mineral aspects. Lasting fruit impressions with lingering oak nuances and lemon drop freshness. $26
92 Beaulieu Vineyard, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Georges de Latour, Private Reserve, Napa Vly
Intense garnet hue. Spicy bouquet of cedar box, mint and pencil shavings. Cherry flavors laced with an earthy, sweet tobacco nuance. Finishes with new oak impressions and a persistent sweetness. $105
92 Bernardus, 2008 Sauvignon Blanc
Griva Vnyd, Arroyo Seco, Monterey Cty
Light citrine hue. Powerful scents of orange blossom, slate and acacia. Creamy flavors of white peach and lemon custard. Impressions of green papaya carry the juicy close. $25
92 Brandlin, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Mt. Veeder, Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Fresh aromas of violets and clove with a notable flintiness. Accessible flavors of black cherry and plum edged by white pepper and mint. Raspy tannins support flamboyant fruit in the spicy finish. $85
92 Buena Vista, 2006 Pinot Noir
Dijon Clone, Ramal Vineyard, Carneros
Dense crimson hue. Complex scents of plum, vanilla and toasted oak with secondary nuances of allspice and espresso. Ripe flavors of raspberry and red plum. Big, refined tannins and layers of cola, mocha and maple in the lingering close. $42
92 Carmel Road, 2007 Chardonnay
Arroyo Seco
Bright yellow-gold hue. Ripe pineapple and dark honey aromas. Flavors of caramel apple and pineapple with a nice backing of youthful acidity. Lengthy, fruit-driven finish with balancing, persistent mineral impressions. $35
92 Chimney Rock, 2006 Elevage
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Solid garnet hue. Cherry cola and coffee bean aromas with new oak and clove accents. Spicy black cherry fruit with a cloak of fine tannins, minerals and lightly toasted oak. Dry, flinty finish with plenty of promising fruit waiting to turn the corner. $76
92 Clos Pegase, 2005 Merlot
Estate, Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Seductive black cherry and glove leather aromas. Soft, creamy texture with ripe plum, cherry and milk chocolate flavors. Lasting ripe black fruit impressions with well-integrated, sweet tannins. $27
92 Dashe, 2006 Zinfandel
Todd Brothers Ranch Old Vines, Alexander Vly
Youthful purple hue. Vibrant, forward aromas of cherry, clove, glove leather and anise. Ripe kirsch and chocolate flavors with well-integrated tannins. Full, expressive finish packed with cherry fruit and a lingering, peppery nuance. $32
92 Domaine Carneros, 2006 Pinot Noir
The Famous Gate, Carneros
Feathered garnet hue. Forward cherry, licorice, leather and orange peel aromas. Well-structured cherry and raspberry fruit followed by earthy garden notes, crisp acids and fine tannins. Light, balanced finish of cherry, orange zest and clove. $68
92 Ehlers Estate, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
St. Helena, Napa Valley
Dense garnet hue. Smoky oak and maple aromas with notes of raspberry, red licorice and warmed chocolate. Lush entry of plum and blackberry fruit followed by youthful wood tannins and crisp, spicy acids. Lengthy black fruit finish laced with drying minerals and an exotic, rose water nuance. $45
92 Etude, 2007 Pinot Noir
Estate, Carneros
Light ruby red hue. Pretty bouquet of smoked meats, spearmint and forest floor. Round, juicy mouth-feel showcases cherry, coffee and black pepper. Spicy notes ring out in the close along with well-integrated tannins and pepper-tinged acids. $42
92 Flora Springs, 2005 tati
Red Wine, Napa Valley
Pale garnet hue. Black cherry aromas with secondary scents of new leather and charred oak. Elegant cherry flavors with an enticing smoky oak nuance. Light, balanced finish with drying tannins and lingering sweetness. $75
92 Gary Farrell, 2006 Pinot Noir
Rochioli Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Pale garnet hue. Cherry and menthol aromas with leather and oak accents. Tart cherry fruit with a defined earthy mineral impression. Dry, flinty finish with an enduring red licorice richness. $65
92 Hewitt Vineyards, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate Grown, Rutherford, Napa Valley
Youthful purple hue. Uplifting bouquet of ripe plum, date and cassis. Supple black cherry fruit laced with graphite and new oak notes. Fleshy black fruit and crisp mineral flavors cap the lively finish. $65
92 Hollywood & Vine, 2007 Chardonnay
2480, Napa Valley
Burnished gold hue. Smoky, charred-oak aromas with secondary scents of baked apple, dark honey and brown sugar. Rich flavors of caramel and apple with a balancing mineral influence. Subtle sweetness lingers in the otherwise dry finish. $45
92 JCB, 2006 Pinot Noir
N°22, Mendocino Bridge
Garnet hue with a feathered rim. A bouquet of cherry cola, charred oak, cedar and pencil shavings. Chalky, red fruit flavors with aggressive, youthful tannins and crisp, nearly biting acids. A compact, tightly wound, well-structured Pinot with plenty of delicious, spicy fruit. Needs time to soften. $100
92 JC Cellars, 2006 Zinfandel
Iron Hill Vineyard, Sonoma Valley
Inky hue with garnet rim. Smoky campfire aromas with blueberry and cinnamon. Port-like texture and weight with minty plum, blueberry and mineral flavors. Excellent staying power loaded with fruit and tooth-sticking tannins. $35
92 J. Davies, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Diamond Mt. District, Napa Valley
Excellent color; purple to the rim. Rich cherry-chocolate scents with notes of oak and dark honey. Compact and crisp with fruit flavors of cherry and blackberry. Youthful, promising cherry-chocolate finish accented by oak. $80
92 Lancaster, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate, Alexander Valley
Black garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Expressive scents of blackberry and plum with a spate of mixed wood aromas. Creamy, soft texture with flavors of red and black licorice. Lasting finish with chalky, fine-grain tannins and drying mineral notes. $70
92 Landmark, 2007 Overlook Chardonnay
Sonoma, Santa Barbara, Monterey Counties
Burnished gold hue. Fresh aromas of orange zest, toasted oak and caramel. Forward peach and apricot fruit infused with vanilla, caramel and toasted oak. The finish is balanced and lengthy with a drying minerality joining the mélange. $29
92 Louis M. Martini, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Alexander Valley
Garnet hue. Mixed aromas of cedar, mint, blueberry and cherry. Supple texture with pure black fruit flavors laced with crisp acids. Plenty of promising fruit, youthful tannins and oak enhance the long finish. $35
92 Lymar Estate, 2007 Chardonnay
Quail Hill Vineyard, Russian River Valley
Bright yellow-gold hue. Ripe peach aromas with notes of caramel and toasted oak. Soft entry of butterscotch, peach and apricot flavors. Sweet, lasting, ripe fruit impressions that finish dry. $40
92 Marimar Estate, 2006 Mas Cavalls Pinot Noir
Doña Margarita Vineyard, Sonoma Coast
Atypical vibrant purple hue. Heady bouquet of menthol and clove with a secondary earthiness. Accessible, juicy black cherry flavors with new oak and well-integrated tannins. Dry, flinty finish with a delicate, lingering sweetness. $49
92 Mazzocco Sonoma, 2006 Zinfandel
Lytton Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Deep garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Uplifting plum, blueberry and mocha aromas. Fresh blackberry jam flavors with youthful tannins and acids. Excellent weight and length with lingering notes of brown spice, plum and orange zest. $29
92 McIntyre Vineyards, 2006 Pinot Noir
Mission Ranch, Arroyo Seco
Medium garnet hue. Complex scents of plum, menthol and white pepper. Sweet, forward flavors of raspberry, cherry and vanilla. Vibrant acidity and lingering impressions of raspberry frame the long finish. $36
92 Morgan, 2006 Pinot Noir
Double L Vnyd, Santa Lucia Highlands
Bright garnet hue. Black cherry aromas with a light charred oak influence. Cherry and clove flavors join an aggressive tannic structure with a hint of peppermint. A well-stuffed Pinot that will continue to improve with bottle age. $62
92 Nickel & Nickel, 2006 Merlot
Suscol Ranch, Napa Valley
Dense garnet hue. Aromas of black cherry, smoke and shoe polish. Ripe flavors of blackberry and raspberry. Plush tannins and impressions of camphor, red plum and orange pekoe tea grace the lingering close. $55
92 Ottimino, 2005 Zinfandel
Von Weidlich Vineyard, RRV
Black-garnet hue. Peppery aromas with whiffs of flint and graphite. Youthful red fruit flavors with a nervy, acidic edge, aggressive tannins and licks of white pepper and citrus peel. A spice-box-of-a-Zin that will flatter a variety of foods. $36
92 Patz & Hall, 2006 Chardonnay
Zio Tony Ranch, Russian River Valley
Bright gold hue. Fresh apricot and peach aromas with a secondary wet stone mineral scent. Ripe peach and caramel flavors with a subtle vanillin influence. Rich, steadfast close with lingering peach, butterscotch and mineral notes. $60
92 Picazo Vineyards, 2005 Estate Merlot
San Francisco Bay, Livermore Valley
Healthy garnet hue. Attractive bouquet of blueberry and plum with notes of vanilla and spearmint. Compact black cherry fruit laced with drying minerals, cedar and redwood. Spicy finish with clove and fine-grain tannins. This second release falls a bit short of the stunning 2004, yet it will outlive its predecessor. Well structured and built to last. $80
92 Provenance, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate Grown, Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Forward aromas of glove leather, black cherry and mint. A spectrum of expressive, ripe black cherry and dusty mineral flavors together with fine-grain tannins. Lengthy finish with plenty of stuffing for aging. $85
92 Raymond, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Generations, Napa Valley
Healthy black-garnet hue. Sweet cherry scents with leather and rose petal accents. Rich, high tone fruit showcasing black cherry and plum. Well made with promising fruit, balancing tannins and fresh acidity in the finish. $85
92 Robert Craig Winery, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Mt. Veeder, Napa Valley
Garnet hue with a ruby rim. A bouquet of cherry and strawberry preserves with notes of pencil shavings and coffee bean. Spicy and minty with youthful, chalky-cherry flavors. A lingering toasted-oak nuance in the finish with a persistent, red licorice-like sweetness. $70
92 Robert Mondavi, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Reserve, Napa Valley
Inky, blackish hue. Menthol-laden bouquet with notes of leather and new oak. Soft plum, blackberry and red licorice flavors laced with fine-grain tannins. Vibrant mintiness, black cherry fruit and new oak prevail in the lengthy finish. $135
92 Rosenblum Cellars, 2006 Zinfandel
Annette’s Reserve, Redwood Valley
Purple hue with a fuchsia rim. Exotic bouquet of raspberry, shredded coconut and toasted oak. Delicious raspberry and milk chocolate flavors infused with calcareous-laden tannins and crisp acidity. Youthful, mouth-puckering finish that will continue to improve. $35
92 Salvestrin, 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon
Estate, Napa Valley
Inky blackish-purple hue. Elegant bouquet with bright red fruit, heady vanilla and light mint. Well-integrated flavors of briary wild cherry and black fruit with a nice integration of maple influenced tannins. Tart and drying on the finish with dominating tannins and pretty vanilla crème brûlée notes that linger. $58
92 Sanford, 2006 La Rinconada Pinot Noir
Sta. Rita Hills, Santa Barbara County
Bright garnet hue. Fresh bouquet of strawberry preserves, bacon fat and buttered popcorn. Round, accessible cherry and strawberry fruit with a smoky nuance shadowing the flavors. Rich, lasting close drinking nicely right now. $45
92 Sbragia Family, 2007 Chardonnay
Home Ranch, Dry Creek Valley
Attractive deep gold hue. Ripe aromas of grilled pine- apple, peach and smoked ham. Flavors of dried apricot and vanilla with secondary oak elements. Supporting acidity joins lingering tropical fruit in the finish. $26
92 Scott Family Estate, 2007 Chardonnay
Dijon Clone, Arroyo Seco
Brilliant yellow-gold hue. Apple, peach and pineapple flavors with a light floral accent. Ripe, tasty apple and pear fruit with an attractive, supple texture. Sweet, lengthy finish with a caramel apple-like richness. $25
92 Shafer, 2006 Merlot
Napa Valley
Inky garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. Heady blueberry and plum aromas with a secondary mineral nuance. Supple, mouth-filling black fruit laced with dusty, graphite accents. Dry, charred oak and an herbal spiciness cap the finish. $48
92 Silverado, 2005 Solo Cabernet Sauvignon
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Black-garnet hue. Fresh raspberry jam aromas with notes of vanilla extract and resin. Soft cherry-chocolate flavors have a vibrant, minty edge. Racy, crisp finish with flinty mineral accents. $85
92 Sonoma Coast Vineyards, 2006 Pinot Noir
Freestone Hills, Sonoma Coast
Pale garnet hue. Reserved scents of wild cherry and raspberry with a hint of menthol. Juicy flavors of raspberry and red plum. Silky tannins and hints of vanilla in the lush, raspberry-driven close. $45
92 Sterling Vineyards, 2006 SVR
Red Wine, Reserve, Napa Valley
Lively purple hue with a fuchsia rim. Fresh plum, blueberry and vanilla aromas. Rich layers of blackberry, toasted oak and mineral. Stylish, lengthy finish with plenty of promising black fruit. $50
92 Stonestreet, 2007 Chardonnay
Red Point, Alexander Valley
Light butter yellow hue. Pretty bouquet of light oak, mint and citrus. Buttery texture with silky mineral notes that showcase apple-laced acidity. Flinty aspects and well-integrated oak flavors emerge in the finish. $55
92 St. Supéry, 2005 Red Wine
Élu, Napa Valley
Pale garnet hue. Light aromas of cherry, graphite and sweet oak. A light-bodied, airy wine with even flavors of cedar, oak, cherry and flint. Elegant and to the point, offering delicate red fruit flavors framed nicely with fine-grain tannins and youthful acids. A contemplative wine to sip and savor. $70
92 Terlato Family, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Stags Leap District, Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue. Exotic aromas of dark honey, chocolate and kirsch. Juicy flavors of red plum, star anise and cherry. Crisp, spicy finish imbued with fine-grain tannins and a lingering, red licorice sweetness. $60
92 Von Strasser, 2006 Cabernet Sauvignon
Diamond Mountain District, Napa Valley
Deep garnet hue with a fuchsia rim. A bouquet of plum and blackberry jam with secondary smokehouse aromas. Accessible, mouth-coating raspberry fruit with a nervy edge of fresh acidity. Lengthy, fruit-driven finish. $50
